Advice Cloud

G-Cloud experts and government procurement consultants

0330 124 4224

  • About
  • For Suppliers
    • For Suppliers
    • Our Services
      • End-to-End Procurement Support
      • Go To Market Assessments
      • Workshops & Training
      • Framework Listings
      • G-Cloud Buyability™ Review
      • Bid Review Services
    • Frameworks
      • G-Cloud
      • Digital Outcomes & Specialists
      • Network Services
      • Data and Application Solutions
      • Technology Services
      • Technology Products
      • Transport Technology & Associated Services
      • Other Frameworks
    • Dynamic Purchasing Systems
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Cyber Security Services
      • Automation Marketplace
      • Spark Technology Innovation Marketplace
      • IoT Technologies Services
      • Digital Technology Services
      • Quality Assurance and Testing for IT Systems
      • Gigabit Capable Connectivity
      • YPO Care Technology
      • HSCN Access Services
    • Why Choose Us?
      • Case Studies
      • Our Experience
      • Our Process
  • For Buyers
    • For Buyers
    • Our Services
      • G-Cloud Support Desk
      • G-Cloud Procurement Services
      • Digital Outcomes and Specialists
      • General Support Services
      • UKCloud Health services
    • Why choose us
      • Our Experience
  • Training
  • Spend data
    • Spend data
    • Spend Data
      • G-Cloud Sales
      • Digital Outcomes and Specialists and Digital Services Sales
  • Resources
    • Resources
    • Procurement Essentials
      • Procurement 101
      • What is a Framework?
      • What is a Dynamic Purchasing System?
    • Ultimate Guides
      • Ultimate Guide to G-Cloud
      • Ultimate Guide to Digital Outcomes and Specialists
    • Tools
      • G-Cloud Sales
      • DOS and Digital Services Sales
      • Procurement Pipeline
      • Framework Alert
    • Resources
      • Blogs
      • G-Cloud
      • DOS
      • Business Guides
      • Expert Insights
      • Research
      • Events
      • Press
      • Videos
      • Announcements
  • Contact Us
End-to-End Procurement SupportGo To Market AssessmentsWorkshops & TrainingFramework ListingsG-Cloud Buyability™ ReviewBid Review Services

Get to grips with the Vertical Application Solutions framework

Join us on Thursday 9th June, 11am until 12noon, for a run-through of the Vertical Application Solutions webinar with our Strategic Adviser and ex-Local Gov CIO, Jos Creese.

BOOK NOW

G-CloudDigital Outcomes & SpecialistsNetwork ServicesData and Application SolutionsTechnology ServicesTechnology ProductsTransport Technology & Associated ServicesOther Frameworks

Get to grips with the Vertical Application Solutions framework

Join us on Thursday 9th June, 11am until 12noon, for a run-through of the Vertical Application Solutions webinar with our Strategic Adviser and ex-Local Gov CIO, Jos Creese.

BOOK NOW

Artificial IntelligenceCyber Security ServicesAutomation MarketplaceSpark Technology Innovation MarketplaceIoT Technologies ServicesDigital Technology ServicesQuality Assurance and Testing for IT SystemsGigabit Capable ConnectivityYPO Care TechnologyHSCN Access Services

Get to grips with the Vertical Application Solutions framework

Join us on Thursday 9th June, 11am until 12noon, for a run-through of the Vertical Application Solutions webinar with our Strategic Adviser and ex-Local Gov CIO, Jos Creese.

BOOK NOW

Case StudiesOur ExperienceOur Process

Get to grips with the Vertical Application Solutions framework

Join us on Thursday 9th June, 11am until 12noon, for a run-through of the Vertical Application Solutions webinar with our Strategic Adviser and ex-Local Gov CIO, Jos Creese.

BOOK NOW

G-Cloud Support DeskG-Cloud Procurement ServicesDigital Outcomes and SpecialistsGeneral Support ServicesUKCloud Health services

Social Value Masterclass #1: Introducing social value in public sector procurement.

Join our sister company Advice Gov’s FREE WEBINAR for public sector buyers on Thursday 26th May, 11am until 12noon.

MORE INFO HERE

Our Experience

Social Value Masterclass #1: Introducing social value in public sector procurement.

Join our sister company Advice Gov’s FREE WEBINAR for public sector buyers on Thursday 26th May, 11am until 12noon.

MORE INFO HERE

G-Cloud SalesDigital Outcomes and Specialists and Digital Services Sales

Grab a copy of our Public Sector Sales & Marketing Guide!

Our expert advisers and staff have put together this in-depth report to help you get to grips with navigating the Public Sector market. Grab your FREE copy here.

DOWNLOAD

Procurement 101What is a Framework?What is a Dynamic Purchasing System?

Download our free Guide to DOS Tenders!

Get expert advice and tips on how to write winning bids for opportunities on the Digital Outcomes and Specialists framework.

DOWNLOAD

Ultimate Guide to G-CloudUltimate Guide to Digital Outcomes and Specialists

Download our free Guide to DOS Tenders!

Get expert advice and tips on how to write winning bids for opportunities on the Digital Outcomes and Specialists framework.

DOWNLOAD

G-Cloud SalesDOS and Digital Services SalesProcurement PipelineFramework Alert

Download our free Guide to DOS Tenders!

Get expert advice and tips on how to write winning bids for opportunities on the Digital Outcomes and Specialists framework.

DOWNLOAD

BlogsG-CloudDOSBusiness GuidesExpert InsightsResearchEventsPressVideosAnnouncements

Download our free Guide to DOS Tenders!

Get expert advice and tips on how to write winning bids for opportunities on the Digital Outcomes and Specialists framework.

DOWNLOAD

Expert InsightsPublished: 25 November 2021

The Oligopoly – did it fight back?

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS

Lindsay Smith goes further into his review of the Digital Marketplace spend data up to September 2021 - asking: Did the empire fight back?

Oligopoly vs SME Digital Marketplace

This is a companion piece to Lindsay’s Digital Marketplace Spending Review to September 2021.

Francis Maude, Baron Maude of Horsham, said of the Digital Marketplace in 2012: “…most importantly we have started to create a competitive and open marketplace from which we buy IT services and solutions – ending the oligopoly of large suppliers and opening up opportunities to new suppliers, including SMEs.”

Then in 2017 he criticised the civil service’s resistance to change and expressed the opinion that the reforms had been “thwarted… and the departments are cheerfully going back to their old ways.”

“[Of the reforms] …For much of the mandarinate this was an assault on their autonomy and empires, and what we know about empires is that they fight back – and boy, are they fighting back.”

Francis Maude2017

So, can we find evidence in the spend figures to establish whether the empires fought back? And perhaps if they did, what’s the state of play?

Part 1: Has Digital Marketplace opened opportunities to SMEs?

Using the data-sets normalised to a 12-month accounting period to September, so we can end with a full 12-months to our most recent data, we can build a sample of SME suppliers on the Digital Marketplace (G-Cloud and DOS) who had become established suppliers by September 2014 and trace what has happened to them.

To find a bellwether sample of our SME community, those who understand how to effectively trade on G-Cloud, but for the present, excluding “super-stars”, outliers which may distort the picture. We first look at the cohort of all SME suppliers with sales between £100,000 and £1m in 2013/14.

The sample of 78 suppliers was reduced to 52 by eliminating suppliers no longer in the spend data in 2020/21 (some no longer trade under their own name; some have become disenchanted with Digital Marketplace and no longer participate).

Comparing the growth of revenues over the 8 years shows this cohort enjoyed strong growth. Comparing the sales of all 52 suppliers between 2013/14 and 2020/21 is summarised in the following table:

Summarised Revenue Stats.

52 Bellwether SMEs (all Lots)

2013/14

(£’000)

2020/21

(£’000)

 

Average (Mean) Sales

 

357

 

3,678

Median Sales 273 1,546
Standard Deviation 249 5,916
 
Maximum 1,000 26,926
Minimum 100 3

 

The high standard deviation, an average well in excess of the median and large interval between max. and min. shows a wide variation of experiences within the cohort. But, if we took the sample average to be a real company, to grow revenues ten time in 8 years is a compound annual growth rate of about 40%.

So far, so good! Opportunity has been delivered and for 33 of the 52 companies this was in the guise of generating more than £1m in sales in 2020/21.

Maybe not so good? At commencement G-Cloud 12 alone had 4,600 SME suppliers. I estimate DOS had a further 1,400 unique SME suppliers providing a total SME supply community of 6,000. We know from the spend data in the 12-months to September 2021 that 1,138 SMEs had at least £1 of sales, meaning 4,862 (81%) are not having any success at all.

But this is not directly linked to our present question ‘did the empire fight back?’ While previous papers, and research I’ve published have articulated, the main reason for this signal failure on the Digital Marketplace is not knowing how to make it work, and not taking advice to make up for this deficit.

So, for the purposes of this exercise, we are going to ignore the 81% and look further into how the Digital Marketplace supports SMEs and then the Large vendors both of which have a sufficient dose of success in their GovTech DNA.

Part 2 – Are the SME “super-stars” very different?

To select this sample, we have taken the 12 most successful SME suppliers (all Lots) in 2020/21 and traced their growth from 2013/14.

Summarised Revenue Stats.

12 “super-star” SMEs

2013/14

(£’000)

2020/21

(£’000)

 

Average (Mean) Sales

 

1,076

 

15,510

Median Sales 481 13,255
Standard Deviation 1,129 6,552
 
Maximum 3,109 26,926
Minimum 27 8,893

 

We can see that the maximum sales figure in 2020/21 is the same in both tables, so at least one of the Core SMEs in the previous sample translated into a super-star and to date is their best performer.

The average sales growth of this cohort gives an annual compounding rate of about 47%. So, it seems that once an SME has “got it” and knows how to do business with the Digital Marketplace, there is opportunity for everyone to be a super-star. At this point, I think we can conclude the objective to open opportunity for SMEs has been and continues to be delivered. Note, this is based on the average case, success is not universal, but it is significant.

Part 3 – What’s the story like for the Oligopoly?

Using the same approach to select a sample of Large suppliers to represent ‘The Oligopoly’, I take the top 12 ‘Large’ suppliers in 2020/21 and trace growth from 2013/14:

Summarised Revenue Stats.

12 Oligopoly Suppliers

2013/14

£’000

2020/21

£’000

 

Average (Mean) Sales

 

2,809

 

85,646

Median Sales 2,224 72,353
Standard Deviation 2,574 27,581
 
Maximum 8,769 132,697
Minimum 42 51,691

 

To use statistics ‘like a drunk uses a lamppost, for support rather than illumination’ is not our way (we can leave that to the professionals, the politicians). So, for balance it’s important to acknowledge that the 3 samples are intrinsically different. Part of the causation behind the greater success of The Oligopoly has to be the ability to scale much more quickly than an SME can in response to (say) increased demand.

But there is a significant disconnect between the success of The Oligopoly perhaps due to ‘the empire fighting back’ and the success of the SMEs. Again, using average sales as a measure, the compound growth of the Oligopoly over the 8-year period is an annual rate of about 63%.

This disconnect is more clear if we graph the 8-year spend data of our 3 samples:

SME v Oligopoly Sept 2021

Normalising the average sales data (by dividing each year’s sales with the average sales for that cohort in 2013/14 – so it becomes represented as ‘1’) SMEs enjoy good and comparatively similar spending through the Digital Marketplace, but the Large enterprises have certainly now fought back and, pro rata, have enjoyed double the share of the public purse going to the SME community.

Have the reforms been “thwarted… and the departments are cheerfully going back to their old ways?” I’ll leave you to decide but it’s certainly not entirely true. Although there are also significant stochastic factors at play: the stresses of the pandemic will understandably push buyers back to their ‘comfort zone’.

The question becomes: is there a coherent political will to continue the initiative to foster and support our SME GovTech community?

I have to say that if there is, it is being kept very quiet.

Digital Outcomes webinar recording

Share

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS

Tags: Digital Marketplace, DOS6, g-cloud 13, Lindsay Smith

Advice Cloud Latest

  • [Infographic] The differences between VAS and DAS
  • G-Cloud 13 is now closed to supplier applications!
  • Cloud Compute 2 framework FAQs
  • Network Services 3 FAQs
  • G-Cloud 12 to G-Cloud 13: How did we get here?
Tweets by @AdviceCloud

Related Posts

  • G-Cloud 13 is now closed to supplier applications!

    The biggest framework this year has just met its deadline! Now that G-Cloud applications are in, what should suppliers do next?

    Read more
  • Cloud Compute 2 framework preview

    Cloud Compute 2 framework FAQs

    The Cloud Compute 2 framework is the second iteration of the recent G-Cloud adjacent route to market. Here's the scoop.

    Read more
  • About
  • For Suppliers
  • For Buyers
  • Training
  • Spend data
  • Resources
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie policy
  • © 2022 Advice Cloud
wiredsussexchambermembertechukCyber Essentials CertifiedcrownsupplierDisability ConfidentBrighton and Hove living wageSussex Business Awards 29InnopsisBlue for Homepage

Advice Cloud Limited | Registered in England | Company Registration no 05776223
Registered Office: Advice Cloud Ltd, 15-17 Middle Street, Brighton, East Sussex, BN1 1AL

We use cookies to improve your website experience. For example we use cookies to show you relevant webinars, content etc.

We have placed cookies on your device to help make our website better. Some of the cookies we use are essential for our website to work.

We also use some non-essential cookies to collect information to provide you with a better experience and to improve Our Site by better understanding how you use it.

You can use this tool to change your cookie settings.

To control third party cookies, you can also adjust your browser settings.