Advice Cloud

G-Cloud experts and government procurement consultants

0330 124 4224

  • About
  • For Suppliers
    • For Suppliers
    • Our Framework Services
      • G-Cloud
      • Digital Outcomes & Specialists
      • Technology Services
      • Transport Technology & Associated Services
      • Medical IT
      • Network Services
      • Technology Products
      • Data and Application Solutions
      • Other Frameworks
    • Our Support Services
      • Buyability™ Review Service
      • Win with G-Cloud
      • Win with DOS
      • Win Public Sector Business
      • Win Central Government Business
    • Our DPS Services
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Cyber Security Services
      • Automation Marketplace
      • Spark Technology Innovation Marketplace
      • IoT Technologies Services
      • Digital Technology Services
      • Quality Assurance and Testing for IT Systems
      • Gigabit Capable Connectivity
      • YPO Care Technology
      • HSCN Access Services
    • Why Choose Us?
      • Case Studies
      • Our Experience
      • Our Process
  • For Buyers
    • For Buyers
    • Our Services
      • G-Cloud Support Desk
      • G-Cloud Procurement Services
      • Digital Outcomes and Specialists
      • General Support Services
      • UKCloud Health services
    • Why choose us
      • Our Experience
  • Training
  • Spend data
    • Spend data
    • Spend Data
      • G-Cloud Sales
      • Digital Outcomes and Specialists and Digital Services Sales
  • Resources
    • Resources
    • Procurement Essentials
      • Procurement 101
      • What is a Framework?
      • What is a Dynamic Purchasing System?
    • Ultimate Guides
      • Ultimate Guide to G-Cloud
      • Ultimate Guide to Digital Outcomes and Specialists
    • Tools
      • G-Cloud Sales
      • DOS and Digital Services Sales
      • Procurement Pipeline
      • Framework Alert
    • Resources
      • Blogs
      • G-Cloud
      • DOS
      • Business Guides
      • Expert Insights
      • Research
      • Events
      • Press
      • Videos
      • Announcements
  • Contact Us
G-CloudDigital Outcomes & SpecialistsTechnology ServicesTransport Technology & Associated ServicesMedical ITNetwork ServicesTechnology ProductsData and Application SolutionsOther Frameworks

Making the most of Digital Outcomes & Specialists 5

Join our upcoming webinar, on Thursday 11th February, 11am until 12noon, to learn how to use DOS5 to win more public sector business.

REGISTER

Buyability™ Review ServiceWin with G-CloudWin with DOSWin Public Sector BusinessWin Central Government Business

Making the most of Digital Outcomes & Specialists 5

Join our upcoming webinar, on Thursday 11th February, 11am until 12noon, to learn how to use DOS5 to win more public sector business.

REGISTER

Artificial IntelligenceCyber Security ServicesAutomation MarketplaceSpark Technology Innovation MarketplaceIoT Technologies ServicesDigital Technology ServicesQuality Assurance and Testing for IT SystemsGigabit Capable ConnectivityYPO Care TechnologyHSCN Access Services

Making the most of Digital Outcomes & Specialists 5

Join our upcoming webinar, on Thursday 11th February, 11am until 12noon, to learn how to use DOS5 to win more public sector business.

REGISTER

Case StudiesOur ExperienceOur Process

Making the most of Digital Outcomes & Specialists 5

Join our upcoming webinar, on Thursday 11th February, 11am until 12noon, to learn how to use DOS5 to win more public sector business.

REGISTER

G-Cloud Support DeskG-Cloud Procurement ServicesDigital Outcomes and SpecialistsGeneral Support ServicesUKCloud Health services

Read our 'Social Value in IT procurement' White Paper!

Social Value seems to be the hot procurement topic at the moment. But, what is it and does it have a place within IT and Digital procurement? Download our free White Paper.

READ NOW

Our Experience

Read our 'Social Value in IT procurement' White Paper!

Social Value seems to be the hot procurement topic at the moment. But, what is it and does it have a place within IT and Digital procurement? Download our free White Paper.

READ NOW

G-Cloud SalesDigital Outcomes and Specialists and Digital Services Sales

Grab a copy of our Public Sector Sales & Marketing Guide!

Our expert advisers and staff have put together this in-depth report to help you get to grips with navigating the Public Sector market. Grab your FREE copy here.

DOWNLOAD

Procurement 101What is a Framework?What is a Dynamic Purchasing System?

Download our free Guide to DOS Tenders!

Get expert advice and tips on how to write winning bids for opportunities on the Digital Outcomes and Specialists framework.

DOWNLOAD

Ultimate Guide to G-CloudUltimate Guide to Digital Outcomes and Specialists

Download our free Guide to DOS Tenders!

Get expert advice and tips on how to write winning bids for opportunities on the Digital Outcomes and Specialists framework.

DOWNLOAD

G-Cloud SalesDOS and Digital Services SalesProcurement PipelineFramework Alert

Download our free Guide to DOS Tenders!

Get expert advice and tips on how to write winning bids for opportunities on the Digital Outcomes and Specialists framework.

DOWNLOAD

BlogsG-CloudDOSBusiness GuidesExpert InsightsResearchEventsPressVideosAnnouncements

Download our free Guide to DOS Tenders!

Get expert advice and tips on how to write winning bids for opportunities on the Digital Outcomes and Specialists framework.

DOWNLOAD

Events, Expert Insights, G-CloudPublished: 30 May 2019

Jos Creese on Government Procurement

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS

Selling IT into Local Government – A New Approach is Needed. The way in which the public sector used to buy IT is no longer fit for purpose.

Jos Creese

Actually it hasn’t been for quite a long time, but old habits die hard. Those habits are not just ingrained into the policies, politics and processes of local government, such as “Standing Orders on Contracts”, and “Financial Regulations”, but also in the way suppliers operate.

For the public sector, procurement practices have developed with good intentions, to try and de-risk IT procurement; after all, the track record of IT projects in the sector have not had a good press. Not only have major public sector IT projects often failed to deliver value (or collapsed outright), but they have often resulted in costly ‘white elephants’. That has damaged the reputation of IT in the sector, but has also made many suppliers wary about doing business, so adding of course to the costs.

Risk and reward

The response has been in many cases the wrong one – procurement practices becoming more sophisticated to try and reduce the risk of this failure – specifying more precisely what is required, making evaluation of tender responses more complex, passing risks on to the supplier where possible. The result: higher cost, longer lead times and ironically greater risk for everyone. That was one of the reasons G-Cloud was born.

But the issues run deeper than this, lying also within the sales methods and models from the private sector. Bidding techniques, terms and conditions, processes and engagement practices which have served the bottom line well in the past, now represent a significant barrier and also a commercial risk – either to leave alone, or to change.

In 2012 the Public Accounts Committee published a damning report titled “A Recipe for Rip-offs” which criticised the private sector and the public sector in equal measure. And in 2011 the Society of IT Management (Socitm), identified in research that outsourcing typically increased costs for local government. Something has been going wrong for some considerable time and we have not yet succeeded in dealing with it effectively.

To be fair, things have improved and most of the old-style large-scale outsourcing deals we saw in the 1980s and 1990s are finally thankfully disappearing. G-Cloud has certainly made a big difference recently, not just in providing a common basis for small and large companies to provide services into the public sector, but also to demonstrate that simpler and faster procurement is possible and delivers low risk and better outcomes. Of course, G-Cloud still needs to be more widely used, and is still developing – but it offers considerable hopes.

Accelerating the pace of change is pressing – the public sector cannot wait, given the financial pressures and growing demands for simpler, intuitive, lower cost and more flexible IT. Small and medium size suppliers have tended to adapt more quickly than the large companies, offering new operating models for selling their services, offering greater flexibility and a different approach to managing risk.  But the large companies are also changing and I have worked with several of the very big names who have fundamentally overhauled their way of doing business and are, as a result, easier to buy from and likely to retain their market share in competition with the smaller companies.

One particular priority is in helping the public sector (and local government in particular) to start to rationalise its software estates. For example, too much data and information are locked into proprietary solutions. This not only makes business intelligence limited, but fundamentally holds back shared services. The former is critical to effective demand management and the latter to reducing costs and better public service outcomes. Local public services will need to integrate software into a common platform of services, removing duplication, maximising sharing and eliminating inflexible contracts.

How can local government go about this?

What local government in particular needs is not more innovative technology, but more flexibility to be innovative in the use of existing technology. It needs to experiment with delivery models, not with technology. And it needs to see suppliers as partners, not adversaries. In turn suppliers need to be part of the delivery of those public service improvements and not just selling a product. How much more satisfying is it for a company to feel it is changing the world, not just making profit? And for this to happen, in a turbulent service environment with rapid advances in IT, suppliers need to be much more flexible, with modular and open-ended contracts, built around a core, but maximising the opportunity for future adaptability. Ironically, this will be in suppliers’ commercial interests in the long run, providing a competitive edge in a market where the customer is increasingly aware.

I am seeing a new software architecture model emerging across local government. It is one that is built around some core corporate systems, but also provides space for a wide range of smaller, cheap and flexible tools, such as smartphone apps. These may not be controlled by the IT department, but are also not ‘shadow IT’, at least in the in the derogatory use of the term. They empower professionals in every service area, and partners, suppliers and service users. They help to generalise digital practice and support mobile and flexible working which provide much needed staff productivity improvement.

In these changes a higher priority is being placed on extracting and sharing data in meaningful ways – between teams, between systems, between organisations. Large scale and complex strategies that talk about sophisticated middleware integration layers and complex CRM and ERP components, are being rightly challenged. They still have a place, but that place is changing. ‘Big data’ is a fact, but please let’s stop using the term in ways which frankly obscure the tangible benefits from better use of information. Labels give IT a bad reputation when their implicit expectations are undeliverable.

As we come out of a period for IT change that is primarily focused on process re-engineering, we are now moving heavily into information exploitation. This means that systems need to hold data securely but not imprison it. Done well and this will allow applications to be more widely used (more people, shared across organisations, from any device). They will also be capable of being more intuitively designed, without compromising privacy and confidentiality which are essential for public trust in digital delivery.

What does the future look like?

G-Cloud for example has simplified and created a more even playing field. It is already allowing procurement cycles to be shortened, with a greater emphasis on investment of scarce resources (time, money, skills, capacity) to deliver value, rather than just investment to acquire a tool kit. Why would any local authority want to use outdated, cumbersome and devalued procurement methods when G-Cloud exists? OK, G-Cloud can’t be used for everything, but can lead the way to streamlining and simplifying early stages of procurement leading to negotiations and testing.

Whilst all this will sound attractive to suppliers struggling with the complexity, variety and slowness of public sector procurement methods, it will also create new expectations of the private sector. There will need to be more openness about contracts and a much higher level of easy integration and sharing. Suppliers will no longer find it easy to provide the same services to neighbouring local authorities on different terms, such as price and flexibility. Pricing low in order to make profit later from change will not be tolerated (or hidden) for example. Neither will playing the ‘FUD card’ (fear, uncertainty and doubt) to drive sales at higher cost from industry leaders; fear uncertainty and doubt is everywhere and contracts need to be agile enough to accommodate the future unknown.

There is also likely to be a move from proprietary solutions, with a preference for open source where possible. This does not mean that there will be no space for proprietary solutions, but it does mean that suppliers will need to demonstrate the openness of their product and significantly greater value, in return for adopting a non-generic solution. The big players such as Apple, Microsoft, Oracle, Adobe and SAP  – to name but a few – all understand this.

So the measure of success in IT sourcing will be from the value extracted from IT, not in the ability to predict the future in tender specification. Local authorities in particular need to move away from trying to over-specify (and over-engineer) tender requirements in a misplaced believe that this will de-risk and increase value. Indeed, reverse is usually true – i.e. trying to specify everything in advance only serves to increase future risk and cost, and so reduces return on investment.

As we move to a digital operating model for local government, it is essential that IT is not a barrier to business change and shared services. Detailed SLAs that previously have underpinned approaches to strategic sourcing may control price, but have been shown to limit value and innovation as well. Whilst more innovation in the use of technology is probably seen in local authorities than in any other part of the public sector, and I firmly believe that this will continue, it is nonetheless dependent on new models of client/supplier relationships, rebalancing of risk in the way software in particular is procured and deployed.  Value comes from adaptability not predictability.

Download our 'What's eating local government?' report!

Share

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS

Tags: G-Cloud, Jos Creese, Local Government

Advice Cloud Latest

  • DOS5 is now Live!
  • Webinar: Making the most of Digital Outcomes and Specialists 5
  • New year, new public sector strategy?
  • Technology Services 3 is now closed
  • What is Find a Tender?
Tweets by @AdviceCloud

Related Posts

  • G-Cloud application roadmap

    [Infographic] G-Cloud Application Roadmap

    We've updated our G-Cloud application roadmap! It features the key steps to getting your application completed in time, and how long each step should take.

    Read more
  • G-Cloud 12 and the Service Definition

    Our Strategic Adviser, Lindsay Smith, looks at why the Service Definition is an essential part of making a success of G-Cloud - especially with its upcoming 12th iteration.

    Read more
  • About
  • For Suppliers
  • For Buyers
  • Training
  • Spend data
  • Resources
  • Contact Us
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie policy
  • © 2021 Advice Cloud
wiredsussexchambermembertechukcrownsupplierSussex Business Awards 29Brighton and Hove living wageCyber Essentials CertifiedInnopsis

Advice Cloud Limited | Registered in England | Company Registration no 05776223
Registered Office: Advice Cloud Ltd, 15-17 Middle Street, Brighton, East Sussex, BN1 1AL

We use cookies to improve your website experience. For example we use cookies to show you relevant webinars, content etc.

We have placed cookies on your device to help make our website better. Some of the cookies we use are essential for our website to work.

We also use some non-essential cookies to collect information to provide you with a better experience and to improve Our Site by better understanding how you use it.

You can use this tool to change your cookie settings.

To control third party cookies, you can also adjust your browser settings.